14 Comments

"Isn't it past your jail time?" is the best shot at the whiny bitch ever. Mockery is the best medicine. I think you guys will find yourselves in the minority. "The way I would've done it" is easy to say, but these people fight asymmetrically. We need to fight asymmetrically as well. Kimmel's shot was a reminder of what we've always hated about Trump. He's a baby. A big fat baby.

Expand full comment

I agree that it was a great show, and Ryan was great with his Ken song. There were great movies in '23, and the production numbers were all great (Billie Eilish). I liked almost all the winning choices, but somehow disagree with your quibbles.

Bashing Trump is Kimmel's thing, he can't resist.

The big thing that has changed in the show is the removal of the lifetime awards and the Academy speech, which lengthens the show too much.

Expand full comment

Anything that mocks and humiliates Trump before a large audience laughing at him is just fine by me.

Expand full comment

I don't get it. If you don't want to feed the troll by mentioning Trump, then why spend the first fifteen minutes talking about Trump?

Expand full comment

My son and I saw Oppenheimer (after driving two hours to see it on 70 mm IMAX) and recently we saw Zone of Interest. They were definitely the best two movies of the year and won the appropriate Oscars.

Expand full comment

Intriguing conversation. I had the opposite reaction to Kimmel’s decision to fill otherwise dead air by reading Trump’s post. I thought it was hilarious and most importantly was not belabored.

Expand full comment
Mar 12·edited Mar 12

If there’s potential Kimmel may have helped Trump by making fun of his juvenile reaction to him on the Oscars — a major party presidential candidate and a talk show host — there’s equal potential, in this evenly divided country, that it helped Biden. We are talking tiny marginal potential among swing voters at this point. Pointing out Trump’s unpresidential trolling is at best a wash, par for the course for what Kimmel does as a host, and another indication of what the country gets with Trump, something objectively mockworthy as well as newsworthy, however predictable his trolling may be at this point; he’s the coin flip choice to lead the free world next January. But point taken on the overall vibe of the Oscars and how it does near zilch to welcome anyone on the right.

Expand full comment

Another great show. As always, I learn, I want to see all the movies -- even the ones I've already seen -- and I feel I've spent some quality time not doing what I should have been doing. Would love to see y'all in DC but I'm going to be in Sonny's backyard (Blanco, near Luckenbach) for the total eclipse and to visit friends.

Expand full comment
founding

Seriously, more self restraint in comedy? Especially from a first class political satirist like Kimmel?

Great podcast, per usual.

Expand full comment
founding

Thanks especially to Alyssa for reminding us that (and why) the Navalny tribute at the opening of In Memorium was SO important in its FILM context. We’ve gotten so used to the ADHD of media it was wonderful to be reminded of the great indelibility and import of some images that would otherwise be lost.

Expand full comment

Ten minutes of talking about Kimmel reading the trump social media post?

Expand full comment
Mar 12Liked by Tim Miller

I agree. Best Oscars in decades. They got so much right for a well needed change.

Expand full comment